CorrectPath
← Dashboard
Module 16 · CSCSAS026 26 min

Assessing the Need for Force

The decision to use force is made in seconds but must survive months of review. Element 1 is the decision: what is the risk, does policy and law permit force here, can I actually do it, and is there anything else that would work. The officer who can articulate this sequence afterwards is the officer whose use of force survives review.

NSWE
The decision sequence points the way: subject behaviour, lawful purpose, call for assistance, lesser options, proportionate option, capacity, then act or contain and wait.

PC 1.1 — assessing the level and nature of risk. The assessment is based on incident risk factors and identified opportunities. Risk factors: the subject's behaviour (verbal, posture, movement toward you, weapons, stated intent); the subject's known history (violence, alerts); numbers (subjects and officers); environment (confined, open, hazards, bystanders); and the officer's own state. Opportunities: a door that can be closed; distance that can be created; a response team two minutes away; a colleague the subject respects; a reason the subject might back down. The assessment is Unit 8's situational awareness applied to one question: how dangerous is this, right now, and what are my options?

PC 1.2 — determining the need for defensive techniques. The decision is tied to the use-of-force guidelines, legal requirements and emergency procedures. The question is not 'am I allowed to' but 'is it necessary, reasonable and proportionate, and does the policy authorise it in this situation'. The learner should be able to work through a scenario and state: the lawful purpose (what am I trying to achieve); the level of subject behaviour under the Department's model; the force option that level authorises; and whether a lesser option has been tried or is not viable. The decision to use force is accompanied by the call for assistance (PC 2.1), not made instead of it.

The decision, as a sequence

1. What is the subject doing, under the model's levels? 2. What is the lawful purpose I need to achieve? 3. Have I called for assistance? 4. Is a lesser option viable? (Communication, containment, time, numbers) 5. If force is necessary: what is the proportionate option under the model, and am I trained and equipped for it? 6. Can I complete it safely, with the officers present, in this environment? 7. If yes, act, with the safeguards. If no, contain and wait. The officer who can articulate this sequence afterwards is the officer whose use of force survives review. The officer who cannot is the one who is investigated.

PC 1.3 — capacity and alternatives. This is the honest question: can I do this? An officer alone against two subjects, an officer whose radio is dead, an officer who is injured, or an officer facing a subject with a weapon is not in a position to apply empty-hand control, and attempting it endangers everyone. The alternative is to withdraw, contain, and wait for the response team. The performance evidence requires selecting a reasonable force option — and 'no force yet, contain and wait' is often the reasonable option. The viable alternatives the learner should always consider: continued communication; disengagement and distance; closing a door; waiting for numbers; a different officer; time.

Scenario · Step 1 of 3

The refusal with a weapon

An offender refuses to lock in and is holding a sharpened piece of metal. He is agitated but not yet moving toward you. You are alone on the wing; the response team is two minutes away. The radio works.

Your first action (PC 1.1 + 1.2):

Match the pairs

Match each decision-sequence step to its question

Item

Definition / Match

Tap an item then its match — or drag from the grip handle straight to its definition. Timer starts on first move.

True or False

'No force yet, contain and wait' can be the reasonable force option that the performance evidence requires.

Reflect

For your site: walk through the seven-step decision sequence for a described incident (a refusal escalating to active resistance). State the subject behaviour level, the lawful purpose, the call you would make, the lesser options you would try, the proportionate option the model authorises, and your capacity assessment.