CorrectPath
← Dashboard
Module 9 · CSCORG050 26 min

Evidence, Law, Bias & Confidentiality

The rules of evidence, the legislation and statutory reporting obligations of the WA justice system, awareness of personal bias, and security, confidentiality and right-to-information principles.

A report written with the rules of evidence in mind is far more useful if it is ever relied on in court.

The formal rules of evidence are a body of law that governs what a court will accept. An officer is not a lawyer and is not expected to apply them, but a report written with the rules in mind is far more useful if it is ever relied on. The practical principles:

- Relevance. Include what bears on the event; leave out what does not. An offender's unrelated history is not relevant to a report about today's assault. - Direct versus hearsay. What you saw and heard yourself is direct evidence; what someone told you they saw is hearsay. Both can go in the report, but they must be clearly labelled so the reader knows which is which. - Opinion. Generally only an expert may give opinion evidence. An officer records facts: 'I smelled alcohol on his breath, his speech was slurred and he was unsteady on his feet' is fact; 'he was drunk' is opinion. - Contemporaneity. Notes made at or shortly after the time carry more weight than a recollection written days later. - Continuity. For physical items (contraband, weapons), the report must show who had the item from the moment it was found until it was secured, with no gaps — the chain of custody. - Consistency with the record. Your report should match the running sheet, CCTV and other officers' reports on the facts. Where it genuinely differs, say so rather than adjusting to fit.

Match the pairs

Match each rule of evidence to what it means for a report

Item

Definition / Match

Tap an item then its match — or drag from the grip handle straight to its definition. Timer starts on first move.

Legislation and statutory reporting in WA. The knowledge evidence requires knowledge of the legislation and statutory obligations of reporting in the learner's own state or territory justice system. For WA adult custody, the instruments the RTO should confirm and insert are the Prisons Act 1981 and Prisons Regulations 1982, together with commissioner's operating policies and directives issued under them. Related obligations likely include the Coroners Act 1996 (deaths in custody are reportable deaths), the State Records Act 2000 (officer reports are state records with retention requirements), and the Freedom of Information Act 1992 (right to information). The RTO must verify each against the WA legislation database before including it in assessment materials.

For the learner, the practical knowledge is: which events must be reported by law or direction (deaths, serious injury, escape, use of force, use of restraints or separation, serious assault, and any others on the site's list), to whom, within what time, and that failure to report is itself a breach with disciplinary and potentially legal consequences.

Personal bias enters at the gaps

Every officer has views about offenders. The common forms of bias in reports: **confirmation** (reporting facts that fit what you expected and omitting those that don't), **characterisation** (loaded words like 'aggressive' in place of described behaviour), **selective detail** (precise about the offender, vague about yourself), **hindsight** (writing the start as if you knew how it would end), **group attribution** (explaining behaviour by race, religion, gang or offence type), and **alignment** (adjusting your account to match a colleague's). The defence against all of them is the same: describe what you saw and heard, in order, in plain words, and let the reader conclude.

Match the pairs

Match each form of bias to how it appears in a report

Item

Definition / Match

Tap an item then its match — or drag from the grip handle straight to its definition. Timer starts on first move.

Security, confidentiality and right to information. Reports contain personal information about offenders and staff and are confidential; they are disclosed only through authorised channels. At the same time, government records are subject to right-to-information law (in WA, the Freedom of Information Act 1992, subject to the RTO's verification), which means an offender or a member of the public can in some circumstances apply to see them. Two consequences for the writer: assume the subject of the report may one day read it, and never include anything you could not justify in front of them.

Scenario · Step 1 of 2

The chain of custody

A weapon is found during a cell search. Write the continuity section from discovery to the evidence locker.

You find a sharpened metal rod in a cell. You (PC 3.1):

Select all that apply

Classify each statement. (Select all that are FACT — a description of what was directly observed)

True or False

Failure to report a death in custody is itself a breach with disciplinary and potentially legal consequences.

Reflect

How would your last report read to the offender it concerns? Is there anything you would change knowing they may one day read it? (200 words)